Matribhumi Samachar English
Kolkata: West Bengal’s political discourse has plunged to a new low after Trinamool Congress (TMC) MLA Madan Mitra made remarks questioning the Hindu identity of Bhagwan Ram, calling Him a Muslim and mockingly asking, “What is the surname of Bhagwan Ram?” The comments, captured in a now-viral video, have ignited massive outrage across the country and reinforced long-standing allegations that the Mamata Banerjee–led TMC has institutionalised anti-Hindu rhetoric and minority appeasement as a political strategy.
While the TMC has tried to portray the controversy as a distortion by political opponents, critics argue that the episode is merely the latest manifestation of a decade-long pattern one that has repeatedly undermined Hindu beliefs, traditions, and cultural identity in Bengal.
In the controversial speech, delivered in Bengali at a public gathering, Madan Mitra began by reciting a Hindu shloka only to follow it up with comments that many saw as deeply offensive and deliberately provocative. Claiming that Bhagwan Ram was a Muslim, Mitra challenged BJP leaders to prove otherwise by asking for Ram’s “surname,” an argument that critics have described as both theologically ignorant and intentionally insulting.
Madan Mitra, a TMC leader and close aide of Mamata Banerjee, known for his rather colourful lifestyle, has now openly insulted Bhagwan Ram and called Him a Muslim. He has even asked, “What is the surname of Lord Ram?”
Earlier, Kolkata Mayor Firhad Hakim called being born a Hindu… pic.twitter.com/xo8bRcpxgu
— Amit Malviya (@amitmalviya) December 19, 2025
Mitra went further, recounting a supposed interaction with a Hindu sadhu who allegedly claimed Ram’s surname was “Ram Jethmalani” a statement Mitra ridiculed publicly. “Would any Hindu believe this? Would they believe such people and go offer their puja?” he said, effectively mocking Hindu devotees themselves, not just political opponents.
The MLA appeared unapologetic and defiant, daring the BJP to take action against him and asserting that he feared no consequences. His remarks, far from sounding accidental, came across as calculated provocation, delivered with confidence that political protection would follow.
BJP National spokesperson Pradeep Bhandari condemned Mitra’s remarks as an outright insult to Hindu faith, stating that the TMC had “degenerated into a party that survives by attacking Hindu beliefs on a daily basis.”
According to the BJP, such statements are not random slips of the tongue but part of a broader ideological ecosystem nurtured under Mamata Banerjee’s leadership one where insulting Hindu symbols carries no political cost, while appeasing radical elements is rewarded.
BJP leaders argue that if a leader from any other party had made similarly offensive remarks about a minority faith, immediate arrests, FIRs, and public condemnations would have followed. The absence of such action in this case, they say, exposes the double standards of the TMC government.
Facing mounting criticism, Madan Mitra attempted damage control by claiming the viral clip was edited and taken from a speech delivered in 2024. He accused the BJP of selectively releasing a 35-second snippet ahead of the 2026 West Bengal Assembly elections to polarise voters.
However, critics point out that editing does not create words that were never spoken, nor does it absolve Mitra of responsibility. More importantly, neither Mitra nor the TMC leadership has offered a clear apology for hurting Hindu sentiments raising serious questions about intent.
The Madan Mitra controversy has reopened scrutiny of several earlier incidents involving senior TMC leaders, Kolkata Mayor Firhad Hakim publicly stated that being born a Hindu was “unfortunate” and expressed his wish for Urdu to dominate Bengal’s linguistic landscape, triggering outrage among Bengali Hindus.
TMC MLA Humayun Kabir’s proposal to build a replica of the Babri Masjid a symbol deeply linked to one of India’s most sensitive religious disputes further inflamed tensions, forcing the party to suspend him only after massive backlash.
These are not isolated incidents but evidence of a systematic ideological tilt, where Hindu identity is repeatedly delegitimised to signal loyalty to a specific vote bank. Perhaps the most telling aspect of the controversy is Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee’s silence. Despite repeated instances of anti-Hindu remarks by party leaders, there has been no arrest, no expulsion, and not even a formal condemnation.
The BJP has also highlighted policy decisions such as Imam Bhata and the steep increase in the Minority Affairs budget, which it claims have grown “by leaps and bounds” over the years. According to the BJP, this sustained appeasement has not strengthened social harmony but has instead deepened communal fault lines, eroding trust and fostering resentment.
Credit : Organiser Weekly
